Which Format is Better for "Cinderella"

[musicradio77]

I'm going to debate on the poll for fans who to see "Cinderella" coming out on DVD on October 4th. If anyone who has the original VHS copy of the same movie, there you go. Tell me, which format is better for "Cinderella"? VHS or DVD.

[Duck Dodgers]

dvd is the best format for every movie.

[corey3rd]

are you wanting us to discuss the "restoration" of Cinderella for the DVD compared to the version on the VHS?

[Sniffles12]

I think this poll is pointless and absurd. :shame: What can be better? Only the DVD.

[Ray Pointer]

Frankly, I'm not sure of WHAT needed restoration on CINDERELLA. Aside from better resolution in the DVD format, what more could have been done aside from eliminating dust specks that may not have been noticed on the VHS release? Cel dust specks were removed in the VHS and DVD versions of SNOW WHITE.

[cbrubaker]

While it would be nice to get rid of the dust caught on film, I'm kinda against getting rid of the cel dusts and scratches, as it is how it's shown in the original. Yes, I'm REALLY that picky about leaving cartoons as is.

[musicradio77]

Frankly, I'm not sure of WHAT needed restoration on CINDERELLA. Aside from better resolution in the DVD format, what more could have been done aside from eliminating dust specks that may not have been noticed on the VHS release? Cel dust specks were removed in the VHS and DVD versions of SNOW WHITE.

As I was point it out, I have the VHS version since I bought it back in 1995. The VHS quality was okay and it needs more work.

[frogboxer]

I think this poll is pointless and absurd. :shame: What can be better? Only the DVD.
Hafta agree with ya there, Sniffles12.

[cbrubaker]

Hafta agree with ya there, Sniffles12.
Ditto.

[Vdubdavid]

I agree that DVD is better because this time around Disney will have hopefully taken the time to restore the RKO opening to the titles as opposed to the Buena Vista card and jump cut!